Prataap Snacks Limited IPO Message Board (Page 1)

U can speak any thing dear u can say 600 also dosnt matter

Do believe in future gamble g .....do not try to be oversmart....what pe 200 .....even a 20% cut on distributor income can give them pe of 40 odd ..... U r much smarter than QIB...QIB portion subscribe by more than 75%......always believe in future

@majitsinghji

Oversmart!!, Even i m not trying to b Smart!!

Just think of below 3 example!

Cap QiB 132x => return only 30%(now)
S chand qib 45x => return ( - 30%)
Apex Qib 2x => return 120%


So neither QiB nor Nii runs the Mkt, mkt always has it''s own fantasy.

If u say in regarding of kwality then

Just tell which one is cheaper,

1> One with m. Cap of 2400 and sales of 6800 cr(Kwality) or

2> one with m. Cap of 3000 cr and sales of 905cr(yellow diamond)

And distributor cut may improve profit eps but here m comparing just revenue which is/ the only positive factor About prataap..!!

M not saying that prataap is not gonna give any return in future but just saying it''s tremendously overvalued based on till date compare to Kwality.


Just take note Kwality is at 102 now and prataap is at 1270.... Reply me after 5/8 months about % of return.

Agree with Gamble ... Result of June qtr is not yet out + look at the delivery volume of yesterday only 16.45% which means people are now worried about valuation & not interested in taking delivery because they know that it can go down anytime. Gamble has rightly mentioned that subscription from QIBs does not guarantee of bright future ahead. It all depends on the performance.

& Many local players are available.For example in gujarat there is balaji which is a highly competitor. Some people are not even aware of this brand ''''diamond'''' in Gujarat. In same way in maharashtra there is lay''s. So I dont think this valuation is justified.

''''highly successful competitor''''

High debt and poor management is reason for kwality dairy to come down from 160 odd levels to 100 rs....moreover management pledges the shares is another reason.....7we cannot compare hdil with that off ibr real estate......whole north india is avalable for prataap snacks to grow.... almost every retail investor is out off this stock....

@ABG ji yes in gujarat, kurkure, balaji is dominant player , you cannot find '''' yellow diamonds '''' easily even if you want !!

@majitji said 2 negatives are priced in already at cmp imo.

Do not fight Manjit & Gamble ji. You both are correct on your views. Remember Dmart is a local player in Maharastra, Karnatka, Gujrat region. When it was listed, people already said that it is most over valued stock. Its valuation went above Wamart at the price of 650 per share. Now same share is trading around 1200. So market has its own course. Nobody knows how market valued the stocks. Pratap Snacks creates fantastic since Salman Khan was endorsing its product and second reason is the sequia capital behind Pratap Snacks.

@Ankurgoel ji..... No not at all fighting.. Everyone have their own opinions and should hv. It''s good and healthy.

Dmart have CAGR of 50% plus damani, and that''s why Mkt hv given 100+PE(what is prataap CAGR?? )

I still regretting not buying d-mart on listing day ????
But mkt hv so many financial powerhouse.

Yeah ..am little worried for Capacit''e. Why it is left behind when everything is rising since last 4-5 days..strange!

When you go for buy an apple. ...
Shopkeeper will try to sell you the least attractive apple First (the one with dark shade, with rashes and suppose to turn out useless after some time ) rather than a good one (with long life/healthy one).... Because he knows that good one gonna sell at anytime but bad one he has to sell first..!!

... Same story indirectly hppns in MKT also
'''' They'''' try to sell least attractive First and make u believe that the good share with enrich funda is unattractive / lacking fancy. Because ''They'' knws the good one gonna be turn into a blast in any mkt condition but lacking funda shares has to offload first with higher rate till conditions are favourable !

Just like

Prataap''s operator : ''Bhai jaldi fancy badha o, logo ko attract kro, topi pahena o, aur nikl lo'' varna mkt down chala jayega fir koi nahi aayega lene!!!

Capacit''E '''' s operator : I don''t care!!!


....... Above lines are just for fun,Unka '''' vastvikta'''' se dur dur koi nata nahi hai...........

Seems On monday they will make it reach to 1350 level & thereafter will start selling.

Is capacite''s june Qtr results declared ?

nice one gamble sir ,,,,,,,!!

u must try to write indian movies dialog also , jst a advice not take serious.

Quantity Traded      24,37,707
Deliverable Quantity (gross across client level)      4,00,956
% of Deliverable Quantity to Traded Quantity      16.45 % very low

@ABG no idea of capacit''E june quarter
@Soq.... RoFL

Very Nicely & Clearly Said Mr.Gamble

Bapu perfect call.

Booked profit in my Four application allotted to me.

Jay ho patidar.