(--APPLY--) PROS- “Company is Debt Free” – There were 3 to 4 bank loans in Draft Prospectus which they may have repaid before filing the Final Prospectus. “First Mover” – There is no listed peer with same or similar product. “Management Expansion” – The company is formed by taking over a Sole Proprietorship !! The 2 New Promoters are from Gujarat.
CONS- “Low Profit in Dec” – Due to high inventory of raw materials. “Related Party Transactions” – RPTs are high but these are reducing in the current FY.
15.1. SSingh| Link| Bookmark|
January 24, 2023 8:39:06 PM
IPO Guru (1400+ Posts, 800+ Likes)
My golden rule, "looking at moon when majority is calling it (the moon) a sun. I will also start calling it (the moon) a sun.". Although did not apply in moxsh, not convinced with their business model. Kuch dimag apna bhi lagao.
Fridabad aa raha hoon Saturday ko, tour karadena facility ka. waise map par facility ke bahar ka road dekhkar ulti aa rahi hai. Kaise kaam karte ho wahan par.
10. Smile✅| Link| Bookmark|
January 24, 2023 5:30:07 PM
IPO Guru (1500+ Posts, 800+ Likes)
This new member @VeteranInvestor promoting issue aggressively on behalf of promoters. Now avoid from my end. Requesting investors to analyse rhp before taking any decision.
9. Trueinfo| Link| Bookmark|
January 24, 2023 3:41:43 PM
IPO Guru (1800+ Posts, 1700+ Likes)
Very small size IPO. Thanks to DD sir for Avoid rating. Subscriptions may be somewhat muted and those wanting to apply may have a better chance of allotment.
Well DD sir recommended 'Avoid' rating for Transvoy also. :D Transvoy is now over subscribed by 180+ times !!!!
9.2. Dilip Davda| Link| Bookmark|
January 26, 2023 11:26:59 AM
Top Contributor (200+ Posts, 300+ Likes)
Please bear in mind that my reviews are based on the fundamentals and the market perception. Operators' game plans are not mirrored as it is anybody's guess. My disclaimer says one should use their own discretion and also consult their financial advisors before taking a final call. Please note my remark on Moxsh IPO which was subscribed over 100 times and see its listing performance and the current status.
Dilip Davda SEBI registered Research Analyst Mumbai
9.3. ipo share| Link| Bookmark|
January 26, 2023 10:19:53 PM
IPO Guru (1500+ Posts, 700+ Likes)
@Dilip Davda Sir, I always read your reviews with great interest before taking decision any decision for applying or avoiding. Your recommendations have been really helpful in decision making on fundamental basis. I hope you will continue this great service. I express my sincere gratitude to you 🙏 🙏
Any review can be a hit or miss for investors. You are not astrologer, that every review will be 100% profitable for everyone.
Your reviews are very helpful, continue the same, don't take anyone comments personally.
Thanks.
9.6. Trueinfo| Link| Bookmark|
January 27, 2023 10:09:35 AM
IPO Guru (1800+ Posts, 1700+ Likes)
@ DD sir, carry on with your good work. Your review gives us a lot of valuable information about the IPO. Some comments, here and there will always be posted, which you may ignore. As you say, besides financials, there are other several factors influencing listing and market price of shares. Applying or not, is individual's choice, but majority give lot of weight to your views.
9.7. Arca| Link| Bookmark|
January 27, 2023 12:33:16 PM
IPO Guru (1000+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
@dilip davda sir Keep doing the good work, don't worry about others comment. Any IPO can be manipulated you can't be responsible for all those things. It would be great if you add peer companies or similar companies based on your experience and not just based on rhp alone. Like you said Bhatia communications for safa, like that kind. Thanks a lot
Poor Drafting or rush drafting in financial Page 145 in screen, Restated Audit report has been prepared in the format prepared for Right Issue (Point 1: DLOF/LOF, Point 2: Proposed RI, Point 5: Restated US GAAP, Point 10: report is for BSE Limited, while company is going to list in NSE)🤦♂️
Company incorporated in March 31, 2022 and giving disclosure in page 159 of prospectus as under: "Our company had positive cash accruals (earnings before interest, depreciation and tax) from operations in 2 out of 3 financial years preceding the date of this Prospectus and its net-worth is positive." 😜
Just chill. Its not for the company but the Firm taken over by the company. How can a company incorporated in 2022 is having financials of last 3 years.
Just wondering NSE is very particular for the drafting of prospectus and they easily observed such kind of mistakes. Its from my past experience
6. SSingh| Link| Bookmark|
January 24, 2023 11:44:09 AM
IPO Guru (1400+ Posts, 800+ Likes)
A BIG AVOID FOR ME…
5. SSingh| Link| Bookmark|
January 24, 2023 6:00:30 AM
IPO Guru (1400+ Posts, 800+ Likes)
Let’s wait for Davda Sir for ‘Avoid Rating’.
Looks a bogus SME to me merely coming to loot investors in this SME euphoria. 😂😂
Too tough decision to make apply which Ipo who has limited funds like me..i have 5lots fund and 2 demats.. please advise seniors better lots to apply to get at least one lot allotment by luckyly.. from belowIPO's Gayatri/Transvoy/Earth alloy