Shalby Limited IPO Message Board (Page 1)

Shalby Limited: The company announced its financial results on Tuesday. It posted an increase in its net profit to Rs. 1019.99 crore for the quarter ended December 31, 2017. The stock should buy on January 10, 2018.

Lol ,1019crs is revenue.

Hi Friends, What is the expected price (Shalby Limited) to sell this Share, I brought it on at 248rs, am holding 50 shares... Please help when to Sell Shelby Limited...

This is the time to buy. hold for long term.

60 shares 248 ke Hai .Kay kare

SHALBY LTD. ANNOUNCE LATEST SHARE HOLDING PATTERN
79.40 % PROMOTER, 19.65 PUBLIC, 0.94 OTHER HOLDING
PROMOTER HOLDING IS VERY GOOD. BUT OR HOLD THIS SHARE

Time to buy this stock, don''t be late.

Sell Emijeatly on Shalby. Continue Low..

Its time to buy more stocks of Shalby. Otherwise you will miss the opportunity just check its price after 6 months !!

Shalby is good management company(+ growing company) their future planning is very good to increase their profit easily for at least some years.

Do u remember the listing of the following IPOs?? They were closed in discount but see their price now same thing will repeat in Shalby.

Eris
Varun Beverages
L&T Info
HCG
Bharati Infratel
SIS

Future supply ipo..is ko rokna chaiey ....ya sale out karna chaiey...

This IPO making loss. Do I sell this ?

Why people are selling share of this profit making company ?

Kya karna chaiey abhi is ipo ka....kab tak cover hoga

Conviction says listing @ 257...

Kaha gya conviction....

Many learned person warn about shalby, but you still holding then,
Target is 165.33 ,wait for that. Amen

See this


11. Market kid Dec 5, 2017 4:31:57 PM IST Reply
Shalby Limited IPO

Forum member must understand what is going on here,

On Nov28 gamble said
Revenue, PBT parallel but PAT swinging widely last 3 year, specially 2016 to 17, just before of an ipo
shalby ''''''''s CA must b good at financing and taxation!!!

On Dec 1 Priyank said
Shalby is not first priority of any local public (Ahmedabad )

Today nidhike suggesting
This will loot u this will koot u!!!!
PBT/PAT crooked.

Now let''''s see what Mr. Septa say !!


I learning financials now a days, and very much amazed why people calculate PE everytime? ?
PE is the last parameter to check upon.

Check EV/EBITDA , EV/PBT, EV/PAT
If all not go parallely then Dal me kuch kala hai, bruh

And check D/E, both line CAGRs, Brand Equity value, Market value, public opinion,RocE

Here EV/EBITDA is 1.5 times than other peers in case of shalby, also debt is too high.

So
Asli value of shalby is 248/1.5 = 165.3333333333 rs.

Wait for that.

Buy @165 for target 200 (due to good news of debt payment and new hospitals coming )

Requesting septa sir to not take PAT on DCF method, because PAT is TRAP here.

You say here PE low, Ronw higher than others,
But

PAT cooked,EPS wrong, PE wrong,

Ronw high due to nw(networth) of shalby is negligeble,Check it, compare it.

Anchor is not smarter than this forum.

Still take your own call only.and be trap for like millions of year.

Keep it up
Good work brother

Please suggest the books so that , we can also learn ...

I think many people here deserve such IPOs. Even after repeated warning, people don''t apply any sense and keep applying to such IPOs. They then end up spamming the forum by asking when to sell and when to hold. If few IPOs have done well, stop being greedy in thinking that every IPO will do well.

Shelby still hold..pls tell what to do ?

I also comment earlier. Dont invest on this type of faltu companies with higher P/E. Leave from this stock, will go down more and more. Hope you will understand.

Down and down

You post about GIC which is still below the issue price and Mahindra Logistics Limited IPO

3. Hiren K. Oct 11, 2017 3:43:29 PM IST Reply
General Insurance Corporation of India IPO

Very Good response from QIB on first day...
4. Hiren K. Oct 13, 2017 8:47:05 AM IST Reply
General Insurance Corporation of India IPO

My personal advice,. Go for GIC ipo, as Every Government company IPO or ofs back up by LIC. and for IPO base price -912 will sustained after LISTIING as government already having backup plan with LIC to maintain base price of 912. So don''''t sell on panic on listing....will not seen down fall.

6. Hiren K. Nov 1, 2017 8:54:05 AM IST Reply
Mahindra Logistics Limited IPO

Except last year performance, no any point to invest on this company on this much price. I agree with Septa sir, totally avoid this IPO.

Hi Friends, Shalby is went down... How many days have to wait atleast get the 248 price.....

Please reply and suggestions please....

Regarding New india Assurance

Currently trading at 45k cr valuation, with HY EPS 15, 1247cr PAT, FY expected EpS 23-25 rs , so PE somewhere 22-24,
BV somewhere 180(current 166)

P/B = 3x currently (545), plus 3% Dividend yeild

So, imo good entry point this range 540-500.

Gic re also good, entry point 750-780, pb 3x Pe 25

=> No big target just kip in mind that this 2 can replace your Bank FD for nxt 5 yr easily at this range.

Yes traded intraday on listing day in nia , some sold that day only in upside, other after hitting SL, now planning to enter without SL in sip mode.

gamble bruh ,see this

Icici Lombard is peer of NIA okay )?

If you see PBT of both then
NIA 3000cr
IL. 1200cr

Now if do m.cap/PBT then
NIA = 15x
IL = 30x

If see Networth wise then new india is 4x of ILGI.

So this much difference shouldn''t be there,

NIA should command 20x of it''s PBT

20*3000 = 60000cr = 720 rs

Learning financial now a days,
It''s so much easy.

Am i right or am i right. ??

Holding 2 lots - what to do? Can hold till 2 months

Can somebody guide?

ET has an article interviewing V.Shah, Shalby promoter, might be an interesting read for some... though I feel, it''s just a face-off between ethics and putting up a good face in front of the media... Doctors who have turned Entrepreneurs are really like pathogen I believe!

Here: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/markets/expert-view/over-last-10-years-we-had-been-growing-more-than-35-year-on-year-vikram-shah-shalby-hospitals/articleshow/62080389.cms

Most people who make forum croaking the basis of their amazing get in / get out excercise would be out before the next trading day is out.. ..Ethics apart, it doesn''t appear as ugly as projected. As the newer capacities turn viable and the debt is retired, the glory would return and return in a style to make most who parted ways, envy....

My suggestion would be to hold till you get minimum 5% return to make up for the selling side brokerage and value for time and hassle encountered to apply plus FD interest of application amount for the period.

You applied to get some return, isn''t it? So, take into consideration of the above... Don''t be in loss.

I don''t apply due to some restriction of non monetary type...but your advice to those who have, is fair and soothing unlike the taunting by the forum''s self proclaimed salvation army...
Keep it up buddy....

Even though combined traded Volume is 1.22 Cr. Shares, Delivery Volume is only 24 lakh shares.