29. YBPK| Link| Bookmark|
July 26, 2023 3:42:36 PM
Top Contributor (200+ Posts, 600+ Likes)
Top 5 customers’ contribution 78.59%, top 5 suppliers contribution 47.95% The key promoter Azharudding Mulla is also promoter of Maagh Advt, its shares offered at Rs 60 are now traded @ Rs 30. Mr Mulla has listed his experience includes apple trading and supply among other things. Poor earnings, poor cashflow One of the directors is an undergraduate, staying in Nashik, and has 1 years experience. Wonder what he is contributing to the company PAT of last 3 years is Rs 111 lacs which is half of increase in debtors of Rs 200 lacs Main asset of the company, after receivables, is intangible asset, software. Company has 11 employees including 4 in management and 7 described as “others”. Statutory auditor of the company is based in Ahmedabad, is it because company is unable to find CA in Mumbai to audit their financials ? Bare balance sheet, poor cash flow, rag tag board of directors, promoter with unrelated experience, poor business visibility.
29.2. Dowg| Link| Bookmark|
July 27, 2023 2:31:41 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 100+ Likes)
If someone is in doubt about applying or not, read @YBPK COMMENTS :)
BTW very good analysis, but all these points or fundamental analysis have no affect on listing of IPO of small issue size.
Dear YBPK Can u share ur major Portfolio Holdings.
29.3. YBPK| Link| Bookmark|
August 4, 2023 1:55:26 PM
Top Contributor (200+ Posts, 600+ Likes)
@Dowg fundamentals matter for investor (people like me) who do not have information about operator / promoter behind the scene dynamics Do not have anything major in portfolio
Hi Noorul, when the financials and LM both are poor, then what is driving this IPO? Cant understand.. Any positives apart from subscription data which I am missing??
27.2. PLAZA| Link| Bookmark|
July 26, 2023 5:47:35 PM
IPO Guru (1800+ Posts, 1100+ Likes)
Not possible at this platform and it works on individual credibility .....
27.3. PLAZA| Link| Bookmark|
August 4, 2023 9:47:51 AM
IPO Guru (1800+ Posts, 1100+ Likes)
Very bad listing without any gain and chance given to retail inspite of that only 3 lac volume , Expecting LC. I sold all application but got NIL allotment
27.4. PLAZA| Link| Bookmark|
August 4, 2023 9:54:30 AM
IPO Guru (1800+ Posts, 1100+ Likes)
Retail 150 times and HNI 50 times and after such huge subscription looks like spectrum.....
@PLAZA just for my knowledge, how much loss the person who bought from you will suffer now? is it around 31K considering you've sold in pre-open for 50?
27.6. PLAZA| Link| Bookmark|
August 4, 2023 12:18:39 PM
IPO Guru (1800+ Posts, 1100+ Likes)
@PeterEngland No loss for buyer and no gain for me as there is NIL allotment
Inspite of such a bad review by Mr. D D and other forum members, the SME is subscribed by more than 10x. It means the investors other than this forum has no idea about negatives of this issue. Mr. D D is giving his review as this forum member or other wise? He is such a senior analyst and his review might be available every in Economic news. In view of today's subscription figures of retail, likely to subscribe not less than 50x but more. Risky SME, AVOID for me, irrespective of subscription figures. Now to wait for listing only and see how effective is the views of Mr. D D. Large number of members have liked his post. But let's see the members who liked his post is going to apply or not. Not possible for us to know.
@PKRAJ Sir, company is paying subject 25k. I think a lot of subscription is coming from grey market deals. Obviously there are people who may get lured into applying after looking at the subscription figures.
21. Trueinfo| Link| Bookmark|
July 25, 2023 11:15:31 AM
IPO Guru (1800+ Posts, 1700+ Likes)
LM's past track record is atrocious and scary to say the least. It almost guarantees discount listing.
Till writing this comment on this IPO, its final prospectus is not available on any public domain like BSE, Lead Manager or the Company's own website. If one visits company's web, they have not yet created Investors page and no upload on its financial performance or board of directors and other compliance matters. This indicates that this company is not keen in sharing info and just wants to collect money from the public. Should investors invest in such company????
Dilip Davda SEBI registered Research Analyst Mumbai
19.1. ipo share| Link| Bookmark|
July 23, 2023 9:27:50 PM
IPO Guru (1500+ Posts, 700+ Likes)
@Dilip Davda Thank you very much Sir for the efforts you are putting in for the benefit of CG forum members. I am sure, your alert will go a long way in saving capital of investors.
Sir @Dilip Davda, If there is no proper description of this said company, then why did SEBI approve for IPOs, instead of delisting it and/or canceling its licence?
Regards, Jeev
19.6. MVP| Link| Bookmark|
August 4, 2023 10:16:36 AM
IPO Guru (1300+ Posts, 1000+ Likes)
This one post saved my time and energy, and I completely ignored this IPO. Thank You Dilip ji.
Every tom dick harry bringing some kachra shop and call it SME and want investor money. This LM should be boycotted such that he think 100 times to bring only decent SMEs. Stay home stay safe.
Stagnant financials. Infact adjust for inflation and it is actually declining steepily. Group company performing poorly after listing. These are clear by just superficial observations. One look at the LM performance, and it is scary. Bloodbath. One must say they are pretty consistent in this (under)performance. GMP if believed, is giving another picture. Unable to rely on it though. Avoid for me.
16. SSingh| Link| Bookmark|
July 23, 2023 5:21:42 AM
IPO Guru (1400+ Posts, 800+ Likes)
Last 7 IPOs are in dark RED. A clear avoid. I WILL SKIP. 🙏🏻
Poor LM record, Company sales are stagnant, trade receivables are increasing, which means company is doing the sales but not receiving the cash. Another group company - Maagh adv is 50% down. Only positive is small issue size. Very risky to apply open. Sell and apply only.