S Chand and Company Ltd IPO Message Board (Page 34)

this is an expensive issue, but listing gain possible. Discl: applied for 1 lot.

Those who doubt ur honestly has no idea of abcd of MKT....let them do that!!!
BTW there r enough ppl who value ur opinion n analysis ....count me +1 :)

Why are you thinking Leave this forum? Its your judgement and I think which was on some basis and valuable for everyone.
I am investor in HNI category.

I stand by you. You have doing a great service by providing valuable and honest opinion to all backed up by sound principles. Great work..
Discl: i have applied for 1 lot just to cash in on this euphoria though i believe your view is right but based on hni subscription i have applied for 1 lot.

I AM NOT LEAVING THE FORUM. AS I SAID AND PROMISED THE FORUM I WILL NOT LEAVE FOR SUCH SMALL THINGS.

sir your calculation is right.. but abhi market trend esa he ki bekkar script bhi bhagti he

ACTUALLY i happy it is oversubscribed at this level so at least if it goes wrong like POWER MECH NOT MANY PEOPLE WILL BURN

Both Septa and Eagleye are doing immense service in this forum to help understand the quality of any given IPO and its expected sucess at listing. They may have divergent views on a particular issue and it''s pricing. But that allows even greater scrutiny, analysis and opinions by other Boarders. The investor should take the ​final decision.

Septa ji is right.

Why taking srsly?? Septaji.. ...

Listing yet to b done..

All r matured here.. ..no one is responsible for anything....this is open forum.. .no one paying a single penny for suggestions. ..

HEALThY talk with contra view should b there ..nothing wrong

Sir
I appreciate you...
Although sometimes you have been proven wrong but it doesn''t mean u r biased or spreading negative news , u have given reasons for your decision to avoid this ipo which is well enough to justify you....
Fake experts join the forum just before ipo and leave it after the ipo....
Let the people talk what they want to talk....
May b this ipo gives the listing gain but its ok nothing to worry, i have also not gone for it.....

Gamble only thing i am serious is my kids. Also nothing wrong in contra view but falsifying is treacherous

few people in forum who know me personnel they tell why u spend so much time on this forum for person of your stature i tell them i love doing and that is enough for me

Yeah 3500+ post.. ...and in every post some kind of information with reasons/expectations/financials is not small contribution.

Just a thought : u should take charge for posting here frm chittorgarh...people don''t care free advice

like The dark knight JOKER''s dialogue

''If you are good at something, never do it for free" ..

...kidding

Ppl doubt bcoz they r taught ever since their childhood " there is no free lunch in this world"
Its neither their nor ur fault....keep doing the great job!!!

Do not listen to the voice of people ,
Do your work as you are doing it honestly
I always says there are bulls and bears ,
One days for a script i am bull the other day i may be bear for the same scrip
Market is volatile , people are blindly investing , let them do so when the market will crash they will not understand which share they should hold or quit

No sir no one think that you are misguiding us we still proud of you that such a selfless person with us . May be some time investor may lead to wrong decisions but u r there to remind us this is share market where any thing can happen. thanks a lot and be with us..

Septa Ji your view is important for every IPO we like your view.

Septa....do not take people like gupa or others demeaning you seriously.....everybody knows this is stock market and each individual learns differently.....Your contribution to this IPO is commendable and highly appreciated...we all are here to learn and share our judgement/experience about the market...so chill and think about Hudco....

Sir, you are absolutely right. The fundamentals​are weak but the market sentiment is very high. So there is overwhelming response.

U r right septa jee.who is questioning they are not mature. So don''t feel otherwise . you always given helpful service to investors

Septa ji
कहावत है कि कुत्ते भौकते है , हाथी चलते है
so ignore it
कुछ तो लोग कहेंगे लोगों का काम है कहना

septa ji
i also think valuation is high but still i applied u share your view on this its good keep it up and ignore some people who think foolish thing

Septa Ji.
You and few people are highly recognised on your forum. And we the laymans rely on your inferences and conclusions.
Your technical analysis regarded it as avoid and so you have proved it.
You dont need to answer all the unreasonable questions in this forum because no one pays you for that.
And also Thankyou for all your technical and fundamental analysis. We do care for you.

Septa sir, I appreciate ur valuable time spending in this forum. We 😍 Sir.

Septaji,
You are the real gem of this forum. We need persons like you here.

so buddy u dint applied on the final day also i also felt that the fundamentals are not that supportive to the price band that company has fixed i also thought not to invest but on the 1st day itself when i saw the subscription figure i thought its definitely going to get subscribed many folds bcoz of the hype nd the brand name so i invested on the 2nd day nd looking at the subscription figure on the last day i think it would definitely fetch decent return of 100-150 rs per share

@septa..considering various views including yours, applied only one instead of decided 3 applications on GMP, but no regrets.. & happy about it.. Pls keep suggesting on IPOs... Very useful for ppl like me... Great job

You should not bother others & We appreciate your valuable suggestions,Pl continue in this forum.Pl do not disappoint many members who have faith in you.

I have not applied too as didn''t like business and financial. This will surely list at premium though due to huge subscription. Best of luck to allotees

We appreciate your valuable suggestions,Please continue in this forum.Nobody pays or earns for others. Its stock market , good valuation stocks can disappoint & may opposite also. You shold not bother about others who says what .Continue ur work with full force.With best wishes & kind regards . All the best for you !!!!

Septa Sir,

1. I like that you are standing with your decision which you made on day 1 based on the financials of the company, which didn’t change in last 15 days.

2. You have clearly provided reasoning about why you are not applying. This is what matters.

3. We all agree with you that “TALK IS CHEAP HONESTY IS VERY EXPENSIVE”

4. Please note that we respect you for your true advices. It cld be +ve or –ve advice, we may like it or not, it may turn in profit or loss; but one thing is sure that a different perspective always helps in taking the decision.

Your explanations help me personally and people I know to understand and make a sensible decision. Thank you for the great work. Keep it up.

Septa ji I need your support. I respect your advice. I didn''t apply.

I agree with your opinion.

I AGREE WITH YOU

I AGREE WITH YOU

I have been following your posts and appreciate your sincerity.

Thank u thank u all I am overwhelmed and overjoyed and humbled 😁 by your support

It was avoid for me as well since beginning irrespective of premium or Anchor quality.

Me too dont applied won''t regretting even if it trade over 800 rs 👍

Septa Sir, I firmly believe in you and your investment ideas..
We know you carry lot of respect & responsibility in this form... Always helped investers​ like us with your honest investment ideas without any negativity/ hype or speculation..
Keep sharing.. S Chand is Ok.. Even if it will open at premium that''s ok..

Mr XYZ hold trading cum demat account, he is buyer and seller of shares. Both Tax liability and profit belongs to Mr XYZ. as per Finance Law

Sir.. If XYZ is relative say daughter / son.. Then who is liable to pay tax... Pls clarify

The seller realizes sale proceed hence XYZ, if in his a/c it is sold, is liable for tax on profit.
However, ABC invested money either as loan or gift. If the IPO amount is refunded through cheque to him, no tax liability on ABC but if it is not refunded and not gift to blood relation, ABC may face preemptive profit if such things found on record various tomes by Assessing Officer.

Aadhar is going to compulsory for trading account soon.

Its 110-113