V-Mart Retail Ltd IPO Message Board (Page 2)

Dilip Davda ji ne SUBSCRIBE diye hai. Koi unki bhi suun lo. Stock Analyst hai 1985 se aur TV par bhi aata hai ( i haven''t seen him). 25 saal ka experience hai. Koi to respect karo :) :)

I recommend avoiding the IPO. Though the fundamentals seem decent, one cannot over-look the fact that V Mart''s scale of operations is extremely small compared to other large retailers. As the resource rich large retailers gradually adapt to small sized formats to penetrate into the Tier III cities, V Mart will have to face some stiff competition. Further, the company also faces the risk of regional concentration given that its stores are clustered in the north and north eastern states. In this backdrop, it is priced at similar multiples to Pantaloon, which makes this issue expensive. My fair value for the company is Rs 175-Rs 180.

Ma''am, woh Davde ji bol rahe hai apne comment mei "reasonably priced" Do you have any comments for him ? Public kafi confho rahi hai soch kar kaun sa analyst sahi hai :):)

The Businessline paper has analysed the IPO in detail .Final summary is being quoted here. "Given the risks and the high valuations, only those investors with stomach for high risk and a medium term perspective can subscribe to the IPO. Investors are also advised against taking a large exposure in the IPO".

This is shameful that someone is making duplicate iD of BABUKALIA.
extremely shameful

I BEWARE ALL NOT TO APPLY THIS STOCK. SEE THE CASE STUDY IT IS SAME AS VISHAL RETAIL SHOWN AS PROFITABLE AT TIME OF LAUNCH. EXIT RITE FOR PROMOTERS.

EVEN CHECK THE BRAND. I HAVE VISITED ONCE IN V2 RETAIL AND IT IS SUCH A 3RD CLASS TO BUY EVEN WORSE THAN VISHAL RETAIL.

THIS STOCK WILL BE WORTH 2 RS AFTER SOME TIME. ONLY PROMTERS WILL EARN AND WILL BE LAUGHING AT TRAPPED RETAILERS.

9. Jinnie
-
LATEST RATE
V-MART GREY MARKET RATE IS 900/1000 MIN APPLICATION RATE
PREMIUM IS 32/34

Don''t be mislead by any- body , look at Koutons , Lilliputs , Cantabils
From 3 figures to penny stock .

Pls. take your informed decisions based upon P/E valuation ( very high in this case )

members (babukalia, ipofinder and sonmaya)
kindly write gmp of VMart please

Dear Friends please give guidance how to purchase OFS shares like OIL India diluted by Govt of India.Thanking you

Same old story with Dilip Davda - a) Retail stocks have already run up due to FDI thus this stock already has FDI policy priced in. b)It is not at all compared to any of it peers as the size of this company is 10 times smaller to the smallest listed retail stock. c)He missed the point that the MD of this company is cousin of RC Agarwal, the promoter of Vishal retail which went bust in 2011.d)Aditya Birla PE arm is offloading their stake in this company. If "FDI" is so called fancy to Mr Davde then why this company suddenly planned to sell their stake when markets are at 20K level. . . Still he is quit wanting to have a subscribed call on it. Investors keep these points in mind while subscribing to it.

supreme court issued notice to center asking how fdi is benifit for inflation,questioning govt policy on fdi and impact on indian shopowner,court may cancel fdi policy if found it wrong.so v-mart may not do well.

issue price is high by rs 100,better if offered at 100-115 .dont thinking this is another vishal retail of future.

SINCE ISSUE IS OF BELOW 250 CRORE , listing day circuit will be 5% and also for 10 days T2T , so not much volume due to only delivery based transactions . one will not get much listing gains

BEFORE THIS ISSUE, OFS OF OIL INDIA IS LIKELY TO DILUTION OF 10% STAKE OF GOI. ISSUE MIGHT BE PRICED AROUND RS.510 AS IT HAS JUST GONE EX-DIVIDEND (RS 11 PER SHARE) AND QUOTES AROUND RS. 530.

ISSUE IS REASONABLY PRICED AND WORTH CONSIDERING. NO DOUBT DUE TO T TAG IT MIGHT HAVE SOME ODD MOVEMENT ON LISTING, BUT OVERALL IT IS SURE TO GIVE REWARDS AS FDI IN MULTI RETAIL IS CLEARED AND THIS COMPANY IS LIKELY TO GET MORE FANCY GOING FORWARD.

Asking price is too high .Listing gain is not expected.

Here is a quote from Smart Investments Weekly, "Given the diluted EPS of Rs. 7.92 of FY 2012 the PE ratio of its share may be worked out at 27.15 based on its upper price of Rs. 215 which is higher than 20.21 PE ratio of Pantaloon. Of course its PE ratio is little bit attractive than its peer companies like shoppers Stop (88.21) and TRENT (68.18.). Considering its book value of Rs. 62.60 the P/BV works out at 3.15. The Return on Net worth (RONW) of this company has been increasingly growing since last three years,which is really a plus point. Investors can subscribe in this IPO from mid to long term perspective''.But, for shot term investors looking for listing gains , there may not be much in the Issue.

hOW CAN ONE COMMENT WITHOUT FINANCIALS.