Manaksia Limited IPO Message Board (Page 23)

Friends, look at the QIB category subscription 3.86 times on
day one . I feel its going to be highly oversubscribed in this
category resulting high premium on listing. So, we should not
miss the issue. Go for it. All the best.

This is one of the best IPO. investor could ever find. The reason being the company is in good industry i.e. packaging [ the most emerging industry as per CLSA & Goldman Sachs ]

Also the issue is very cheap in terms of PE

Dear Pink

We value your views and opinion. In future please type your comments in small letters. It is extremely difficult to read your comments. Please take in future

I believe all others who are regular to this site will accept my views.

Regards and have a great week

Kamal.

what is the use. heavy oversubscription is going to ensure the money is locked and possible low allotment chances...thats the order of the IPOs these days. Look at BGR and Transformers. Ppl have become IPO aware nowadays and everybody wants to make quick money.

DEAR SHIVA (31)THANK YOU VERY MUCH . WHAT I HAVE STATED IS A FACT SEEKING OPINIONS OF FELLOW INVESTORS. WHAT YOU WANT TO DO IS
ABSOLUTELY YOUR RESPECTFUL DECISION AND OPINION . aPART FROM ABOVE i HAVE NOTED THAT THOUGH cO;S SHARES WERE QUOTED IN cAL.STKeXCH AND INSPITE OF NO TRADING FOR LAST THREE YEARS THEY HAD NOT TAKEN ANY STEPS TO GET THE sHARES LISTED AT NSE/BSE WHY ? PERHAPS THEY DIDNOT REALISE THE PLIGHT OF EXISTING SHARE HOLDERS tHERE IS NO ANSWER FOR THIS. tODAY THEY ARE ASKING THE PRICE EQUAL TO TATA STEEL AND RELCOM LIKE CO'S. WITH DUE RESPECT TO THE mANAGEMENT MOST HUMBLY AND RESPECTFULLY I ASK WHAT DIVIDENDS THEY WILL GIVE HOW THEY WILL REWARD THE INCOMING NEW SHARE HOLDERS. tHE PROSPECTUS SAYS COST OF THE PROMOTER sAHARES HOLDER PER SHARE IS JUST EIGHTEEN PAISE ONLY. SINCE tHERE ARE OTHER INVESTOR FRIENDLY CO'S LIKE THIRUMALAI CHEM , SESHASAHI PAPERS LIKE SHARES WHICH ARE AVAILABLE AT MUCH LOWER PRICES THAN THIS AND HAVE OVER THE LAST MANY YEARS CONSIDERED THEIR DUTY TOWard the Share holders . IT IS FOR INDIVIDUAL TO TAKE A JUDGMENT WHETHER HE SHOULD OPT INVESTOR OR NOT THANKS VERY MUCH PLEASE GIVE YOUR COMMENTS .

dear pink

ur final report abt MANSAKIA is to buy or to avoid

thanks

I HAVE GONE THROUGH AVAILABLE INFORMATION ABOUT MANSAKIA WE MUST
UNDERSTAND THAT CO. HAS GIVEN CONSOLIDATED PROFITS OF SUBSIDIARY COMPANY THIS GIVES LITTLE INFORMATION ABOUT STAND ALONE CO. 'SPROFIT . AN ORDINARY INVESTOR WILL BE BENIFITED ONLY BY THE NET PROFITS OF THE STAND ALONE CO. SUBSIDIARY CO'S PROFITS ONLY HELP MANAGEMENT AND NOT THE SHARES HOLDERS . ALSO CO IS SILENT OVER DIVIDEND PAYMENT POLICY. PLEASE NOTE BANKS WILL NOT BE ABLE TO OBTAIN FIXED DEPOSITS IF THEY SAY THAT INTEREST PAYMENT IS AT THEIR SWEETWILL AND DISCRETION. SAME IS TRUE OF CO. 'S SEEKING PUBLIC EQUITY FUNDS THEY MUST DISCLOSE THEIR DIVIDENDS POLICY TO CREATE FAITH
IN INVESTING PUBLIC OTHER WISE WE ARE AFRAID INVESTOR PUBLIC MAY BE PUT ON A VERY EMBARRASING AND LOSING PROPOSITION. THIS DEFINITELY REQUIRES A THINKING POINT AMOUNG THE INVESTOR. WILL APPRECIATE OTHER FELLO INVESTORS COMMENT. THANKS FOR READING THIS.

best ipo to be applied

thks imran

IPO Raja told its 80.

why most of u r discouraging.???this is definately gd issue avail. @ low pe with gd expansion plans.will any one tell me its gray mkt premium??????????

why most of u r discouraging.???this is definately gd issue avail. @ low pe with gd expansion plans.will any one tell me its gray mkt premiun

HI CAN ANYONE GUIDE ME ONE SHULD APPLY IN THIS IPO OR NOT.......................

Hi Visu

Thanks for your response...

Need to get some more inside information before applying...looks okay.

Regards

To my knowledge this IPO is very much good for Listing gains...
Apply to this...

Hi this is visu...
Reply to (18. InveSTAR)

The shares of the company are presently listed on Kolkata exchange but not traded as the company has just 143 shareholders as on date.

hi,
in my view this is not so good looking ipo, but how ever this time all ipo are listed on premium prise so i think we should try for minimum bid quantity so we retailer's do n't fill that we miss this after listing at premium prise and if got loss than it is littel loss

KETAN PATEL,VADODARA

Company has good markering pipeline & already listed in CSE. it means it has long term view for its expansion & though its related to metal products it seems growing plus GMP is 60-70 rupees on max 160..............overall its good ipo....must subscribe.

Hi

At what rate is the scrip trading in Kolkata Stock Exchange? Does any body have any idea....it will help a lot to decide whether to go for it OR go OUT of it :-)

Cheers!!!

If I apply on the closing day of the IPO and my mode cheque, after how many days (approx) the amount will be withdrawn from my bank.