HDFC Securities(HDFCsec) is Equity Trading Company of HDFC Bank. HDFC Securities provide both online trading and trading on phone. The HDFC Securities trading account has a unique 3-in-1 feature that integrates your HDFC Securities trading account wi...
I want to close my trading acc HDFSEC becaof high charges,But I tried motilal also it is same.they are charging diffrent way some you don''t understand,atleast HDFCSEC answer and explain if you ask something,but the motilal never answer simply reply contact our frenchisy . better invest your money but not in stock be cathese brokers are eating your earning,and if you loose also they charge.
Borkerage charges are very high. They are not folloiwng the charges specified in portal and dont know how the system will calculate.
Most of the times i didnt understand on what basis they are calculating brokerage. Same kind of volume and script they have charged diffrently.
FOr each sale transaction charging extra 25rs other than brokerages and which is not specified any where. I have enquired about this and did not get propoer response from HDFC and telling that this is for all the customers.
243.1. Swamy S Mar 9, 2013 4:44:43 PM IST |
Brokerage for delivery segment with Hdfc securities is 0.50% or min Rs.25/- with ceiling of 2.5% on transaction value on both buy & sell on each trade. and for intraday segment it is 0.05% or min Rs.25/- with ceiling of 2.5% on transaction value on each trade For Eg- If you purchase 100 shares on delivery @ Rs. 45 / share. Total transaction value = Rs.4500/-
Brokerage. 4500) which comes to Rs.22.5 is lesser than Rs.25 , so Min.Rs.25 will be charged on that trade, taking into consideration it is not exceeding the ceiling of 2.5%
There are dp transaction charges on selling the shares from the demat account which is levied by hdfc bank.
242. kunti kunwar Feb 1, 2013 2:26:29 PM IST | Reply
I am having dmat account with HDFC securities. I am doing trading with phone for ordering the trade. The problems are that the staff at Madras branch are not attending the call. The reason I presume is due to over flooding of calls from the customers. In share trading every second counts. Can you make arrangements to speedy attention of customers in order placing.
They say no annual charges but they charge annual folio maintaince charges between 750rs to 300rs making it one of the most expensive. If you compare it to say icici it may look the same but if you look at the features once you login hdfc is very basic you cannot really tract the profit loss or trades or any other thing.
241.1. Roger Jan 24, 2013 4:59:51 PM IST |
Hi Vipin,.. you can downthe p&l report online from your trading account, following the link History> sec settlement > Equity profit & loss report, and for the demat annual folio maintaince you should contact Hdfc Bank demat desk on 61606161.
Iam a frustated customer of hdfc bank''s demat/brokerage services. They are very costly and poorest service providers. I have no words to express my frustation. Iam taking an exit from their brokerage account.
Brokerage - Below Average Account Maintenance Fees - Below Average Website Usability - Excellent Customer Service - Very Poor Overall Experience - Below Average
NEVER OPEN ANY TYPE OF TRADING A/c WITH HDFC SECURITIES.IF YOU ARE OFFLINE TRADER THEN THE PEOPLE WORKING THEIR WILL GIVE TRADING TIPS WHICH WILL DEFINITELY REDUCE YOUR CAPITAL. I HAVE TOTAL EXPERIENCE WITH THESE PEOPLE & EVEN THE BROKERAGE CHARGED BY THEM IS MANY MORE TIMES HIGHER THAN ANY OTHER BROKERAGE COMPANIES.
Brokerage - Very Poor Account Maintenance Fees - Very Poor Website Usability - Very Poor Customer Service - Very Poor Overall Experience - Very Poor
238. C.ARABINDOW BASKARAN Dec 9, 2012 10:32:46 AM IST | Reply
I am having dmat account with HDFC securities. I am doing trading with phone for ordering the trade. The problems are that the staff at Madras branch are not attending the call. The reason I presume is due to over flooding of calls from the customers. In share trading every second counts. If we miss the target to sell or buy we will be loosing thousands of rupees. Can you make arrangements to speedy attention of customers in order placing Due to some personal reason I am unable to maintain minimum balance in my savings bank account for which I am penalised Rs. 393x4 Rs.1572 by debitting from my account. This forces me to look for some other banks to do trading.Govt banks like SBI allow us to maintain O balance.
Mobile trading facility is available with Hdfc securities through blackberry, Android phones & tablet java , window based phones, iphones http://www.hdfcsec.com/ContentPages.aspx?docid=201102110500561662414
HDFC charges huge depository charges.If you combine them with the brokerage charges, it eats up your profits considerably.
Brokerage - Below Average Account Maintenance Fees - Very Poor Website Usability - Above Average Customer Service - Average Overall Experience - Below Average
235. anil sharma Oct 26, 2012 6:37:50 PM IST | Reply
I had gone through compare chart in which hdfcsec .com is showing Demat AMC charges as nil but practically they charge heavely. Also every sell carried out by client is charged @20 Rs for demat account which is not shown in table. Any Reply.
Hdfcsec.com says they charge .15% on intra-day but their bills state .71%. this is a clear case of misguiding customers. Any reply from there end.
235.1. varun Nov 1, 2012 5:43:17 PM IST |
I suggest that for dp charges you may contact at 022 61606161 with Extn - 5 or write an email to Email as its charged by HDFC Bank Depository section.
However, brokerage for intra day HDFC Securities Ltd., charge 0.05% or Rs. 25/- on each side also brokerage structure is updated in their website
234. Rakesh Kumar Verma Oct 26, 2012 12:14:02 PM IST | Reply
Hi I am using of HDFC SEC Dmat account. Brokerage charges is very high and bank also charge as depository Rs.25 +service tax per sale separately.So now i have decided to close of depository service of hdfc sec.
Brokerage Charge- Very high Account Maintenance Fees - Very High Website Usability - good Customer Service - Very Poor Overall Experience - Very Poor
Costomer service from HDFC Securities is fast and result oriented... in my experice as compared to ICICI Direct.
232. rajesh lulla Oct 3, 2012 9:11:24 PM IST | Reply
brokerage is on the higher side .... rest all is good. reduce minimum brokerage to Rs 15 and 0.2% delivery and 0.02% intra day (for online trades) . options brokerage should also be reduced to Rs 50-75 per lot . if they can do it these guys will beat competition hands down . customer service is excellent.
Brokerage - Below Average Account Maintenance Fees - Average Website Usability - Above Average Customer Service - Excellent Overall Experience - Excellent
Trading in HDFC Securities is a good experience. Portfolio is well designed. Cost price and current price are available in portfolio. It shows the profit / loss in portfolio. Its easy to trade on HDFC than ICICI Direct.
Brokerage - Excellent Account Maintenance Fees - Average Website Usability - Excellent Customer Service - Average Overall Experience - Above Average
229. Bijender Kumar Sep 19, 2012 9:57:17 AM IST | Reply
Good service provided by HDFC Sceurities, web site based trading plateform good but DP charges cut monthly from the account is very surprise, how much they may cut ia can not under stand the formulae for monthly DP charges. I am maintaining my account since August 2008.
Brokerage - Very Poor Account Maintenance Fees - Very Poor Website Usability - Excellent Customer Service - Above Average Overall Experience - Below Average
229.1. Kevin Sep 24, 2012 5:31:09 PM IST |
Hi, I agreed with your comment towards the HDFC Securities Ltd. However,i suggest that for dp charges you may contact at 022 61606161 with Extn - 5 or write an email to Email as its charged by HDFC Bank Depository section
WHAT HAD HAPPENED TO ME , I THINK HA NOT HAPPENED WITH ANYBODY . I GOT A JOB IN PUNE IN HDFC STANDARD LIFE 2008. SO THEY OPENED MY SALARY ACCOUNT, WITH THAT CREDIT CARD ALSO, AND EVEN THEY OPENED MY DEMAT ACCOUNT WHICH I NEVER WANT THAT TIME. COZ EVEN I WAS NOT AWARE OF A SINGLE THING IN SHARE MARKET. AS MY BOSS INSISTED OR CUD SAY FORCED ME TO OPEN DEMAT ACCOUNT. AS FOR CREDIT CARD I GOT BENFET , NO BLAME FOR IT . BUT FOR DEMAT I GOT SCREWED UP . THE KIT NEVER REACHED MY HOME . BUT WHEN AFTER 3 YEARS IN 2012 AUGUST , SUDDENLY I HAVE GIVEN A CHEQUE TO SOMEBODY TO CASH FROM MY ACCOUNT . THE CHEQUE GOT BOUNCED DUE TO INSUFFICIENT FUND . DO U KNOW WHY? BECA800 RS WAS DEDUCTED FROM MY ACCOUNT AS AMC AFTER 3 YEARS . WHICH I WAS NOT AWARE AND NOBODY HAD TOLD ME OF THAT . EVEN HDFC SEC PEOPLES HAVE NEVER INTIMATED ME . AS I WAS NOT AWARE OF THAT I HAVE TO CLOSE THAT DEMAT ACCOUNT. WHEN FINALLY I CLOSED IT UP , I SUFFERED A LOT . EVEN I ASKED THEM THAT I HAVE NEVER TRADED , OR EVEN I HAVE NEVER GET THE OPENING KIT . I GOT A REPLY THAT ITS COMPANY POLICY. SO UNETHICAL HDFC SEC DIVISION IS I CAME TO KNOW . AS I AM A DAILY TRADER SINCE LAST YEAR IN IIFL . IT IS GOOD .
227. GAGAN BAJAJ Sep 6, 2012 11:56:59 AM IST | Reply
HDFC has very poor customer services. I am thinking to close my account pretty soon.