FREE Account Opening + No Clearing Fees
Loading...

Mishra Dhatu Nigam Limited IPO Message Board (Page 2)

Loading...
172. Karan Sen |   Link |  Bookmark | April 13, 2018 12:49:20 PM
Can someone explain me the reason for such a surge in price of this stock? I exited at 100 but now its at 108. Regret it now.
172.1. dpcdsl |   Link |  Bookmark | April 13, 2018 3:11:08 PM
Top Contributor Top Contributor (400+ Posts, 200+ Likes)
Boom in all metal scrips hence MIDHANI surged.
172.2. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 13, 2018 3:13:19 PM
It is very low equity
orissa mineral and nbcc too when can with ipo of such small size became multibagger

wont be surprised if this can go on same line and will increase investor wealth
171. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 10, 2018 9:26:50 PM
Highly advanced technology. Experienced team like nbcc. Strong customer relationship high margins. This stock is a must as portfolio stock .keep adding this gem .it will reward and will be another nbcc . Stock has consolidated around 90 levels and will move higher. One of the best stock to invest and will slowly and steadily move higher
171.8. Cautious ipo |   Link |  Bookmark | April 11, 2018 11:04:16 AM
IPO Guru IPO Guru (1900+ Posts, 1100+ Likes)
Will buy 1000 for medium term.
171.9. Cautious ipo |   Link |  Bookmark | April 13, 2018 12:44:08 PM
IPO Guru IPO Guru (1900+ Posts, 1100+ Likes)
Hats off bhai
170. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 13, 2018 10:46:38 AM
After NBCC i am very positive on this one
NBCC went on to go 12 times its issue price in 2 years/

keep adding this gem as a must in your portfolio stocks.
170.1. Karan Sen |   Link |  Bookmark | April 13, 2018 11:17:58 AM
You were spot on, I had received full allotment for 15 lots. To be honest I even tried to cancel but it was too late. But I don't regret it now. Sold it for 100, pretty good returns I say.
170.2. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 13, 2018 12:29:26 PM
congrats to everyone for making money in this excellent company

for long term investor this is a stock to just buy and forget as it will be wealth creator stock in long run.
169. Cool Sunshine |   Link |  Bookmark | April 10, 2018 5:58:09 PM
- Current issue is an OFS so IPO proceeds will not go to company.
- IPO doesn't add much value to the company as no additional funds will be available for the company.
- Company's main production unit had a long shutdown in FY18 which will cause the company's production to be significantly lower.
- With lower product available to sell this FY18 revenue is expected to be drastically down and also PAT.
- With shutdown, additional cost of maintenance as compared to last year, hence logically profit% margin of FY18 will also be down unless company shows cost cuts in other areas.

With plant shutdown & offer being pure OFS, there was no need to take risk by applying in this IPO. Next results are also not expected to be very good. How the price of this stock is going to be impacted by results will be decided by market and speculators. I cant predict that. Take your short and long term call accordingly.
169.1. Parvati Shah |   Link |  Bookmark | April 13, 2018 12:10:06 PM
Mishra dhatu trading above 100.

Hope as usual, people negative on this stock should not claim to bought at 90 and sold at 100.
168. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 13, 2018 12:09:20 PM
Bhai logon I was telling to buy since many days.
Intelligent people must have know the potential of this company. it has rewarded everyone

NBCC ki kahani repeat hogi
167. Aniketiaf |   Link |  Bookmark | April 13, 2018 11:49:28 AM
IPO Guru IPO Guru (1800+ Posts, 10200+ Likes)
Sold 02 lots @ 104
Kept 01 lot for better return.
166. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 11, 2018 10:52:03 AM
Hahah. Never knew God will answer so soon. Mishra exim up 5 pc now at 94 rs which means 10 pc gain with firm allotment. There will be no comments now from coolsunshine urf ipobull. this shows how u were trying to pick up negativ e but did not mention multiple positive things. A great answer to coolsunshine
166.2. ipobull |   Link |  Bookmark | April 11, 2018 10:57:02 PM
IPO Guru IPO Guru (1000+ Posts, 1000+ Likes)
Don't confuse me with Cool shine. Just because he is also holding my opinion, do not think we are same. I don't care about your Midhani's movement as I'm invested in stocks like Bandhan Bank, Avenue Supermart, Interglobe Aviation, etc. which have given me handsome returns since I've accumulated from secondary market also. I damn care about what you say about Midhani. I would only advise boarders not be invested in underperforming sector like steel. It lacks the X-factor and cannot make huge movements on the upside. Do remember my words.Hope you don't loose cool again. Even if u do, I don't care as I'm always a bull.
166.3. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 11, 2018 11:19:40 PM
u both are same

by the way today it went until 96 rs and the stock has given good returns.
i rest my case as u already proven wrong
noone wants your wrong reviews
165. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 11, 2018 2:03:49 PM
Cutie another fake ID of coolsunshine. since coolsunshine cant reply with hid ID creating new ID to reply

just imagine how cutie bought at lowest price today and sold at highest price. lol

yeh public hai yeh sabe jaanti hai
165.1. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 11, 2018 2:24:05 PM
Please show screenshot of ur trade and can get verified from SEBI
If the proof is not given then 100 pc u r coolsunshine and making faking stories
164. Cutie |   Link |  Bookmark | April 11, 2018 1:11:13 PM
This message has been removed by a moderator.
164.2. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 11, 2018 1:36:39 PM
will go back again and cross 100 soon

anyway some stocks reward everyone and this is good company where everyone will make money those who have patience as well as those who exit in short run
164.3. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 11, 2018 2:01:44 PM
Yes maine nbcc bhi kharida hai aur short term traders kharidte rahe aur bechte rahe aur 3 saal mein 15 guna hogaya.

not concerned with market volatility. will keep for long term. stock market hai upar neeche toh hoga hi.

itni achi company aur kya chaiyeh investors ko. sab kuch toh hai
debt free, good margin, good dividend
163. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 11, 2018 12:43:11 AM
people please see below message.
ipobull is a fake id of coolsunshine
he himself is not letting others write freely and come my way on my every message shows how frustated he is .


140. Cool Sunshine Apr 6, 2018 1:04:29 AM IST I Like It. 9 | Report Abuse
Top Contributor Top Contributor (400+ Posts, 1700+ Likes)
All of us are so emotional about our stocks picking, thinking, knowledge and everything that we dont think that there can be another perspective from equaly (if not more) competent individuals. This temperament leads to shouting and attacks on each other.

Suggestion:

Let us all post our opinion in our own threads (not as a reply to someone elses message) unless thread starter has an explicit query and solicits response/opinion from other forum members. This way every one will be able to share their opinion openly and multiple perpectives/opinions can co-exist side by side without any issue/conflicts.

Open to any other suggestion to improve tener of discussions in forums.
avatar
139. IPOANALYSIS Apr 4, 2018 11:16:48 AM IST I Like It. 1 | Report Abuse
IPO Mentor IPO Mentor (700+ Posts, 400+ Likes)
NOT BAD LISTING
ALTHOUGH I AM NOT CONFIDENT OF OTHER PSU IPO BUT THIS ONE LOOKS GOOD IN ALL ASPECTS

REMEMBER EVEN NBCC WENT DOWN ON LISTING DAY AND WE ALL KNOW IT HAS GONE TO BE 12 TIMES ITS ISSUE PRICE NOW

BUY FOR LONG TERM INVESTORS. THERE IS NO COMPETITOR AND ALSO ITS VERY CHEAP AT SUCH LOW P/E
Hide comments
avatar
139.1. ipobull Apr 4, 2018 3:07:42 PM IST I Like It. | Report Abuse
Please do not misguide boarders of this site. Do you know a part of the MIDHANI's manufacturing infrastructure is locked? Hope you are monitoring stocks like NHPC, which can languish at around 20-30 levels for a lifetime unless there is some magic news.
163.4. Cool Sunshine |   Link |  Bookmark | April 11, 2018 1:26:57 AM
I don't have to correct anyone by SHOUTING at him/her or asking him to SHUT UP or by calling him DOG or MAD or some other abuses. Check your thread with that ID, I am nowhere in that thread.

I gave the suggestion to keep separate threads so that members don't have to SHOUT at others to say something.

Believe me I am not frustrated as you tend to believe. I can go on and on... and have infinite capacity to stand again unnecessary online bullying, attacks and abuse.

Request you to understand politely once again the following
1. Recognize that there can be other way of thinking other than u and respect that.
2. Irrespective of degree of disagreement or difference of opinion, abuse ..shouting and attack on others cannot be justified.
163.5. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 11, 2018 9:26:52 AM
At one side u r saying everyone is free to write anything.on other side u favour ipobull which is ur fake id when he is writing on my thread in such manner and now u say its ok to.have different opinion. U are not sticking to ur own words. stop pretending. Anway keep writing negative words on this stock and the price of stock will.give u best answer.
162. Cool Sunshine |   Link |  Bookmark | April 11, 2018 12:57:05 AM
Message to Moderator

I have made enough requests to this ID IPOANALYSIS and tried everything to let people communicate freely, not to shout and not to use abusive language.

I have been courteous and polite enough all through to make him understand but this ID is just not relenting.

I once again request to re-publish the website policy for forum use, language and freedom of opinion and speech for everybody's benefit and in case of any violation of the same, take appropriate action.
161. Cool Sunshine |   Link |  Bookmark | April 10, 2018 6:44:12 PM
IPO watch: Midhani, a national asset, but risky for investors

Read more at:
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/markets/ipos/fpos/ipo-midhani-a-national-asset-but-risky-for-investors/articleshow/63391069.cms
161.1. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 10, 2018 9:30:27 PM
Thank u. This article has good reviews . Debt free ,high dividend. good margins,small issue size. What else u want. Favourable . A must portfolio stock
161.2. Cool Sunshine |   Link |  Bookmark | April 10, 2018 10:28:23 PM
As always shared the whole article, It is upto individuals to interpret as I don't suppress facts. Revenue and margins trend shares in last article. Article says dividend payment is regular. I could not locate where is it written that dividend is high. Below is the Midhani dividend history.

Dividend per share of INR 10.

FY 2017. INR 1.89
FY 2016. INR 1.79
FY 2015. INR 2 00
FY 2014. INR 2.00
FY 2013. INR 2.00

Please note that this dividend is on the face value of 10. Now the share has been issues at INR 90, the above dividend yield should be divided by a factor of 9.

No-one can impose their verdict on anyone hence I don't have to share my verdict. Investors are intelligent themselves to interpret and arrive at their own verdict.

Since you have been continuously barging in threads opened by me, please do not feel offended when I also do the same.

Thanks for using civil language and normal case in your post. Appreciate it.
160. Cool Sunshine |   Link |  Bookmark | April 10, 2018 5:30:49 PM
Message to Moderator

I thought if you publish the non-abusive policy some better sense will prevail but I think it is not possible.

Yes.....please investigate all my messages....and messages, responses and language used from IPOANALYSIS and MASTRAM. Timestamp should clearly help in knowing who is instigating who is instigating whom.
159. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 10, 2018 5:24:39 PM
verdict: Healthy Long term prospects and not for ST

at rs 90 per share company mcap will stand at 1686 crore which discounts FY17EPS by P/E of 13x while fy19 p/e stands at 10
Midhani enjoys monoply position in titanium alloys manufacturing in the country and also meets the needs of defence/space sectors
retail discount of 3 rs is attraction
Going forward company aims to increase R&D spend to 5 % of sales from current 2 %

The stock can be quality mid cap play delivering consistent returns over the long term

given its unique story and sound fundamentals comopany can be good portfolio play strictly with medium to long term view

https://www.sptulsian.com/free-zone/ipo-analysis/Mishra-Dhatu-Nigam
158. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 10, 2018 5:15:17 PM
message to moderator

Request you to please take into account fake id or multiple id been created by same person.
there must be some way like IP ,emails to identify. Coolsunshine have created a fake id with name of ipobull to instigate people and keep writing long emails.
look at his emails he is repeatedly posting same message again and again and multiple times

this can be verified by looking at previous post. due to his bad experience with PSU and heavy loss he has been out of his mind and targetting each and every company now

also his repeated messages shows he need some medical help soon


142.8. Cool Sunshine Apr 6, 2018 5:07:14 PM IST I Like It. 7 | Report Abuse
Top Contributor Top Contributor (400+ Posts, 1700+ Likes)
Again CAPS lock and shouting.

Please note that I started this thread and you start countering me and not the otherway around.

Anyway keep shouting.
157. Cool Sunshine |   Link |  Bookmark | April 10, 2018 4:20:32 PM
Message to Moderator:

Request you to please re-publish the permissible language policy for Chittorgarh.

There are IDs who are calling members DOGS, Lunatic and using words like SHUT UP and so on and so forth. Some of these IDs have not stopped intimidating other members by shouting in ALL CAPS, despite multiple polite request not to do so.

Politeness and courtesy for other members is too much to ask from them but at least a bare minimum non-abusive language can still help in maintaining sanity in IPO forums.

Please re-publish the policy.
156. Cool Sunshine |   Link |  Bookmark | April 10, 2018 3:57:09 PM
Revenue trend --------------------DOWN
PAT trend---------------------------DOWN
Profit % trend----------------------DOWN

FY year--------Revenue in Rs Mns-------------------PAT in Rs Mns---Profit %age

FY15-----------6783.8-------------------------------------991.6---------------14.6%
FY16-----------7904.1-------------------------------------1193.7-------------15.1%
FY17-----------8330.9-------------------------------------1263.1-------------15.2%
FY18(H1)-----2206.6-------------------------------------273.0---------------12.4%



Its revenues grown from Rs 678 Crores in FY15 to Rs 833 Crores in FY2017. However, its revenues for 6 months ended Sep-17 has fallen to Rs 220 Crores.. Company says there is shut down of one of its main plant after 32 years for maintenance and it would re-open from Apr-18. It would post reduced revenues for FY2018 compared to previous years due to this impact.

Almost all online articles also have articulated that plant shutdown will impact revenue and PAT of FY18.
156.1. Cool Sunshine |   Link |  Bookmark | April 10, 2018 4:00:51 PM
Data is as per following article:

https://myinvestmentideas.com/2018/03/mishra-dhatu-nigam-ipo-midhani-ipo-what-are-the-hidden-factors/
155. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 9, 2018 11:34:19 AM
COOLSUNSHINE doesn't have any work apart from writing huge useless mails.
only time will prove him about this stock

i never started it. u started it and now getting taste of your own medicine
155.2. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 10, 2018 1:49:45 PM
ipo bull urf coolsunshine fake id
its does not matter what u say. the stock is giving profit with confirm allotment so why are you barking like a dog

anyway dont act stupid market is up only .25 pc so it hasn't moved.

please shut up and do ur work and dont try to create havoc in this forum
155.3. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 10, 2018 2:00:40 PM
ipobull dont act stupid

eagleeye had good view on this stock for long term
u r proving urself incorrect . hahaha
154. Cool Sunshine |   Link |  Bookmark | April 9, 2018 11:54:02 AM
I avoid (almost every time) writing anything to counter someone in his/her thread but no one can stop me sharing my views separately on forum..............Period.

I will not respond to unnecessary provocation. I would have discussed with this ID very calmly and openly on Shutdown and everything else, if there was some sense of courtesy shown to other forum members. But unfortunately he/she is here not for discussion but for some other purpose.

Whether stock moves to 200 from currently 90 or to 30, I will earn money in both situations but there are some people who don't understand at all what others are saying , I cant help it but just ignore.
154.1. IPOANALYSIS |   Link |  Bookmark | April 9, 2018 12:41:19 PM
get well soon
154.2. Cool Sunshine |   Link |  Bookmark | April 9, 2018 12:54:22 PM
Continue.......
153. Cool Sunshine |   Link |  Bookmark | April 6, 2018 9:40:14 PM
Dear All,

I have requested Uchit Patel to help us in this regard. Please see my below post.

I am ready to unconditionally and openly apologize if he says I have brought him down in HAL forum.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
220.2. Cool Sunshine Apr 6, 2018 9:37:40 PM IST I Like It. | Report Abuse
Top Contributor Top Contributor (400+ Posts, 1600+ Likes)

Dear Uchit Patel,

Recent this ID Mastram put an allegation on me in "Mishardhatu Forum" saying "See HAL forum, how he indirectly brought down Uchit patel ".

I request you to please let the forum know if and how I have brought you down.

Please write in the forum openly. From the bottom of my heart, I want to understand.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
153.1. Cool Sunshine |   Link |  Bookmark | April 9, 2018 11:35:51 AM
Response of Uchit Patel in HAL forum in this context

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
220. Uchit Patel Apr 7, 2018 7:50:56 AM IST I Like It. 4 | Report Abuse Reply
Top Contributor Top Contributor (400+ Posts, 1100+ Likes)

All,

I don't have any problem from anyone's comments. Everyone has right to express his/her views.
I request everyone try to not blame anyone. Respect everyone's views. We have many new investors and they want to learn investment. This is stock market. No one is God. No one can predict future of stock market perfectly.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------